To fish,
they may
have to
fight
Charter
operators
organize in
hopes of
changing
regs
By McKibben Jackinsky
Staff writer
|

In 1988, Steve Smith was
intent on developing a
successful charter fishing
business in Ninilchik. In
the years since, Smith has
done just that. His
single-boat, bed and
breakfast operation has
grown into Captain Steve's
Fishing Lodge, a two-boat,
$1.7 million enterprise that
not only keeps Smith's
family working, but also
provides employment for nine
full-time summer employees.
Smith's business has been
cut in half, however, by
National Marine Fisheries
Service's new Charter
Halibut Permit program for
areas 2C, Southeast, and 3A,
the central Gulf of Alaska
including Cook Inlet and
Kachemak Bay, which goes
into effect Feb. 1.
Under this program, only one
of Smith's boats has been
granted a permit. The second
boat failed to meet minimum
participation standards
during the program's
qualifying years of
2004-2005.
Full
story
Skippers at Sea Over a
License to Fish
Federal Officials
Curb Permits to Alaska's
Chartered Halibut Fleet to
Stop Overfishing, but Some
Boat Operators Fear Ruin
Federal
Government Wages War On
American Dream In Alaska And
Beyond
By Cal
Kellogg
Back in
January I wrote an article
outlining how the Federal
Government has instituted
arbitrary and highly
restrictive rules governing
charter boat fishing for
halibut in southern Alaska,
while Alaska’s state
government has stood idly by
as jobs, businesses and
tourism revenue are in
peril.
In that article I explained
how the Feds have sided with
commercial fishing
interested and have imposed
a complicated set of rules
that will exclude 40% of the
charter boats currently
operating in southern Alaska
from fishing, by not issuing
them permits.
As anglers residing here in
California are well aware
the Federal Government in
the form of NOAA Fisheries
has a long and depressing
record of implementing
restrictions on anglers with
little evidence that the
restrictions are even
necessary. Basically they
cite “the best available
science”, generally science
that would receive a failing
mark in any entry level
science or social science
classroom in any college in
the country, and then make
sweeping regulations that
both strip away the rights
of sport anglers and have
broad economic consequences
for businesses and
communities that rely on
sportfishing dollars for
survival.
If you are a California
saltwater angler think about
the MLPAs and depth
restrictions that have been
shoved down our throats
along with the prohibition
on harvesting canary
rockfish, which are larger
and more plentiful every
year and you’ll have a
pretty good idea of the
federal level incompetence
that I’m talking about…’nuff
said.
There have been some
developments in the Alaskan
situation that I’ll address
in a bit, but first I need
to touch on how Jane
Lubchenco, NOAA’s
Administrator is pushing for
the privatization of public
trust fisheries under a
program known as “catch
shares”.
Now I’m not going to use a
lot of complicated double
talk to explain how catch
shares work. I’ll use
layman’s terms because I
don’t want to be confused
with a politician.
Certainly this is just my
opinion, but when I start
hearing a lot of complicated
double talk coming out of
government agencies or
politicians I just figure it
is a smoke screen that they
use to attempt to cover up
the fact that they are A.)
Stealing from us B.) Taking
away our rights or C.) Both
of the above.
President Obama’s 2012
budget defines Catch Shares
as “a general term for
several fishery management
strategies that allocate a
specific portion of the
total allowable fishery
catch to individuals,
cooperatives, communities,
or other entities."
On the surface it sounds
like Catch Shares would
institute a system of
fairness in allocating fish
to everyone, but that isn’t
the case. It would create an
exclusionary system where
the large commercial fishing
corporations would get the
lions share of the catch,
leaving small commercial
operators, charter skippers
and recreational anglers to
fight for the leftovers, if
there turned out to be any
leftovers once the
privileged few harvested
their bloated quotas.
Ultimately if the
administration’s Catch
Shares program is
implemented many commercial
anglers and sportfishing
skippers will ultimately be
pushed out. Catch Shares
will strip away American
jobs, signal the death of
countless small businesses
and in the end will lead to
outsourcing sea food harvest
to foreign nations that have
no regard for conservation
or food safety…Hence the
title for this article.
Catch Shares represent the
worst form of social
engineering. If you’d like
an in-depth overview of the
situation and learn what you
can do to help derail the
program visit the Saving
Seafood website at
www.savingseafood.org
and look up the press
release titled “Recreational
Fishing Alliance Says
Environmental Defense Is On
The Offensive”.
Now let’s get back to the
Alaskan situation. Charter
skippers in Alaska continue
to be bullied by both
commercial fishing interests
and the Federal Government.
Despite the fact that
charter operators and sport
anglers only take less than
20% of the total catch,
commercial anglers have
asserted that this is too
much and the Feds largely
agree with them.
Both commercial anglers and
the Feds assert that charter
fishing pressure is on the
rise, yet between ’07 and
’09 sportfishing pressure
dropped and the reported
catch declined by 24%.
Despite this reduced
pressure and catch Rachel
Baker of National Marine
Fisheries Service is quoted
as saying, “…it doesn’t seem
like there is continued
growth (among charter
operators), but we’re still
going ahead with the
program.”
True to form the Feds are
punishing charter skippers
and sport anglers despite
the fact that the data just
doesn’t add up.
Alaskan charter skippers
have asserted that the new
regulations restricting the
sport halibut harvest will
have far reaching economic
implications to the state of
Alaska as a whole that the
Feds have failed to
consider. Commercial fishing
creates jobs there is no
doubt but the economic
influence of sport anglers
is very broad going far
beyond the dollars they
spend directly on fishing.
Sport anglers purchase
airline tickets, rent cars,
frequent restaurants and
taverns, book hotel rooms
and buy mementos of their
visit.
On January 14, NOAA reacted
by calling for a survey of
limited scope pertaining to
the economic impact of
sportfishing. Yet I found
the wording in the press
release to be troubling. It
stated, “...all data will be
handled confidentially. Each
individual survey will be
handled only by the
researchers and destroyed
upon completion of the
study. Only summary survey
results will be reported to
the public…”.
Okay you want the people you
are trying to force out of
business to take your word
for the results of a
confidential survey in which
the data will be destroyed
rather than released for
public scrutiny? Give me a
break!
Julie Speegle was the
government mouthpiece, I
mean NOAA representative,
listed as a contact at the
top of the press release. I
called her and she was out
of the office and I never
got a call back. Her office
number is (907) 586-7032 and
her cell phone number is
(907) 321-7032. Perhaps she
could explain the strengths
and weaknesses of NOAA’s
seemingly flawed economic
impact survey to a few
hundred Fish Sniffer
readers.
As for the Alaskan Charter
skippers, they are still
seeking contributions to
their legal defense fund and
they have a petition up and
running on their website
where you can voice your
support in the fight to save
sportfishing for Alaskan
halibut. Please visit their
website and lend a hand
www.charteroperatorsofalaska.org.
Cal Kellogg
Family Fun
August
2010
We arrived in Anchorage on
July 18th at noon, made the
160 mile drive to our
vacation home
in Clam Gulch,
dropped
off our baggage and
groceries and were on the
river by 6:PM. I hadn't
planned on fishing the first
evening but the kids were
determined to have bent
rods plus it was my 49th
B-day. What better gift
could a dad have than
spending the evening hooking
salmon with his kids?
On this trip were my
son Jake 17, his two close
friends Brandon and Brian
and my 15 year old son
Tyler. Joining us were Tom Fueer,
Casa Grande High School
teacher (of all four kids)
who started the incredible hatchery
program at the school, my
sister Beth and brother
Pete and my wife's brother
Len and his family from the
east coast.
On his second cast Tyler
hooked the first sockeye of
the trip and by 9:PM were
were filleting limits. Returning home
for dinner we had fresh BBQ
sockeye fillets instead of
the planned chicken.
The
sockeye fishing was fast and
furious over the next two
weeks. The Alaska DFG
increased the sport limit
from 3 to 6 fish on the 5th day
of our stay and the fish
literally started to "pile
up". By the beginning
of our second week we had
filled enough fish boxes to
feed our families for the
coming year and went to
catch and release. (though
the boys always kept a fish
or two so they would have an
excuse to flirt with the
girls at Custom Processors)
We worked a number of areas
for sockeye from the public access areas
on the lower Kenai to a couple of friends
backyards who are blessed to
have riverfront property, to
hike in spots on the upper
river around Jim's Landing.
It wasn't a manner of if we
were going to catch fish, it
was how many do you want to
hook.
We did a few day hikes to
check out the upper Russian
river around the falls and
while the sockeye fishing on
the Russian was slow the
crowds were light, the
rainbow action incredible
along with a few
opportunties to watch the
bears feed.
With the high flows the king
action was tough so we opted
to concentrate on sockeyes
and leave the king fishing
to the pros. Val Early from
Early fishing reported some
huge fish this past week
with kings to 60 pounds
though most kings were
smaller fish this season.
The
razor clamming was good with
big crowds turning out to
take advantage of the -5
foot tides and easy limits of 60 clams per
angler were the rule.
The clams were smaller this
year but the biomass along
the Ninilchik beaches is
high and futures years
should be incredible.
We got in just one day of
halibut fishing with Steve
Smith with easy limits of
halibut running from 30
to 70 pounds. Two weeks go
by in a hurry when you are
having this much fun and we
are already looking forward
to next July!
Mike
We are looking ahead to
another fun packed summer so
come on up and join in on
the action. If you have any
questions regarding our
USAFishing's
Kenai Peninsula CABIN
or the fishing or the Kenai area in
general please give us a
call at 707 762-9776. We
will be more than happy to
assist you.
For Sale 2 + acres Ocean Front in
Anchor
Point, Alaska
This 2.35 acre ocean front
parcel is the ideal location
for your dream retreat.
Fronting Cook Inlet on one
of the most westerly lots of
the Kenai Peninsula and just
a half mile south of the
Anchor River, renowned for
strong runs of king and
silver salmon, steelhead and
Dolly Varden.
Panoramic ocean and mountain
views (Iliamna, Redoubt and
Augustine) as well as
wildlife, whales, seals and
otters. The nearby boat
launch provides easy access
to incredible saltwater
fishing and clamming.
Fire
and road service area.
Adjacent 2.35 area lot is
also available. Both parcels
have been improved and
cleared with driveway access
off borough maintained
Danver road with electric
and phone at lot line. There
are only a few ocean front
lots available on the Lower
Kenai Peninsula and
waterfront land values
continue to remain in high
demand. $120000. each
Please contact Dwaine at
Trails End Reality for more
details. 907 235-8244 /
isell4u@ptialaska.net
Caught Fish? Looking for timely informative updates? Check out a FREE trial to the Northern California Hotsheet, California's fastest growing fishing newsletter. The Hotsheet is emailed three to four evenings per week direct to your desktop. No hunting the web for information or waiting on an outdated magazine to arrive in the mail. These in-depth reports keep you on top of what is happening TODAY so you can catch more fish tomorrow! Just $3.50 per month when you subscribe for one year. You can receive a free week's trial copy by e-mailing a request to fishsite@aol.com
|